7 Best Key West Gay Resorts & Stays (2023 prices)
By Varsha & Adi | Updated on July 12, 2023
In a world that’s as diverse as a bag of Skittles, it’s crucial to create safe havens where everyone can taste the rainbow of acceptance, regardless of their sexuality or gender. But the sad truth is, even in 2023, there aren’t many places that’ll let us be who we are.
So, imagine my surprise when I found Key West, the ultimate gay paradise. Key West not only just lets you be, but also actively encourages it. Be it gay hotels or all LGBTQ-inclusive guesthouses or adults-only inns or clothing-optional resorts, there is a treat for everyone at Key West.
Why Key West Is The Ideal Vacation Spot For LGBTQ+?
“One human family”
That’s the motto of Key West, Florida. It is internationally known as “Gay Mecca”. The destination is renowned for its welcoming and accepting attitude. The accepting atmosphere of Key West attracted LGBT travelers, nurturing a thriving LGBTQ+ culture with supportive bars, businesses, and organizations. It served as a haven during times of widespread discrimination.
In all, Key West is the gayest of the gays!
Seriously, this place embraces you for who you are, no questions asked. It’s a rainbow paradise where everyone’s free to love and be loved, without any judgment. The people are friendly, the drag shows are out of this world, and you’ll find yourself surrounded by a community that understands and supports you.
Whether you’re partying on Duval Street or soaking up the sun on the beaches, you’ll feel like you’ve found your tribe. So in case you are planning your Gay-cation 😉, Key West will be your dream destination.
You May Also Like
Island House Gay Resort
Vibrant social scene and opportunities to make new friends
Alexander’s Guesthouse
An LGBTQA+ guesthouse
Our top picks
1. Island House Gay Resort
Key West
1. Island House Gay Resort
Google rating: 4.7
Known for
- Exclusive LGBTQ+ destination for gay men
- Vibrant social scene and opportunities to make new friends
Location
Situated in the gay “Guesthouse Row” in Old Town, at the end of Fleming Street. This is six blocks from Duval Street, or about a twelve-minute walk at an easy pace.
Specifically, they are at the corner of White Street and Fleming Street.
Resort Features
Island House Key West has been called “The Best Gay Resort in the World” by several national and international publications, including OUT Traveler and The Travel Channel US and UK.
- Happy Hours: From 5 PM to 6:30 PM, the resort turns into the most fabulous big gay party! Free cocktails galore! Even in-house guests get four on the house!
- Clothing Optional: Step into Island House Key West, and you’ll think you’ve entered a gay-friendly nudist paradise! No clothes are needed! Except in the gym… thanks, State Law!
- Pool Parties: Wednesday and Sunday gay-friendly pool parties are wilder than a flamingo in a tutu! Come & dance at their clothing-optional resort.
- Amenities: Their 24hr Cafe and Bar will feed your belly and quench your thirst day and night! Plus, a sundeck with a misting system – sunbathing like VIPs!
- Sauna and Jacuzzis: Want to get steamy? They’ve got saunas, Jacuzzis, and steam rooms – all at your service 24/7! Just hop in whenever you feel like it!
- Extra Discounts: Hey students, military folks, firefighters, and law enforcement! They love you so much they’re giving you 20-30% off! Live your fantasy and save some cash!
LGBTQ+ Inclusivity:
This is one of the few male-only key west gay resorts. But women and non-males are welcome to stay in their detached wing which has no access to the clothing optional area to protect the male guests’ right to privacy when nude.
Room Features:
Each room at Island House Gay Resort is thoughtfully designed to provide modern amenities, including air conditioning, a hot tub, flat-screen TVs, and complimentary Wi-Fi. Guests can also opt for private patios or balconies, allowing them to bask in the island’s natural beauty.
Pricing:
Basic Rooms at Island House Gay Resort begin at $260 per night for shared-bath options. Two-bedroom suites offer a top-tier experience with rates reaching around $530 per night.
2. Equator Resort Key West
Key West
2. Equator Resort Key West
Google Ratings: 4.7
Known for:
- Clothing-optional pool
- Complimentary happy hour
Resort Features:
- Happy Hours: Get ready to vibe with the daily happy hour from 5:00 pm to 6:30 pm, hooking you up with 4 free well drinks, beer, and wine per person. But wait, there’s more! During happy hour, all extra drinks hit you with that sweet 50% off deal.
- Pool Bar: It’s the spot where the gang gathers to sip on the dopest drinks and let the laughter flow. Good times guaranteed!
- Sun’s Out, Clothes Optional: Find your zen on the clothing-optional sundeck, soaking up the island vibes with like-minded peeps. No stress, just good times.
- Epic Amenities: In this fab gay resort, it’s all about good vibes. It may be smaller, but it’s got that cozy charm that’ll warm your heart. And get this: you’re in for a wild ride with ELEVEN different adult male channels right in your room! Ooh la la!
- Petits Débuts – Fancy Morning Treats: Continental Breakfast? Nah, They’ve got something better! It’s a complimentary grab-and-go adventure packed with tasty goodness! Stuffed Croissants, Mini Quiches, Pastries, Bagels – all locally made, all for you, every day. And they’ve got all your breakfast staples too – cereals, yogurts, bananas, oranges, milk, OJ, and oatmeal.
- Small & Personal: If you’re all about that exclusive gay, clothing optional resort but don’t need a massive resort, this is THE spot to be. Island House who? They’ve got you covered!
LGBTQ+ Inclusivity:
This is one of the only two male-only clothing optional Key West gay resorts. To protect the right to privacy of their male guests, no women or non-males are allowed into the resort.
Room Amenities:
The Equator Resort Key West offers 34 unique rooms converted from 5 historic properties, each exuding its own charm. 24-hour front desk assistance ensures guests easily find their perfect room and location.
The following are the features of the room:
- Mediterranean tile floors
- King, Queen, or Double Queen bed options.
- Saratoga sparkling water, robes, refrigerator, microwave, iron, and ironing board.
- All rooms are smoke-free, with smoking permitted in designated outdoor areas.
- Wet bars, skylights, and two-man whirlpool hot tubs add to the memorable experience for all guests.
Pricing:
Room rates at Equator Resort Key West vary depending on the type of accommodation selected. On average, the minimum price per night for a room starts at approximately $200, while more luxurious options can go up to $500 per night.
3. Alexander’s Guesthouse
Key West
3. Alexander’s Guesthouse
Google Ratings: 4.9
Known for:
- Embracing LGBTQ+ Celebration
- LGBTQ+ Friendly Haven
Location:
Nestled on the edge of Florida, Key West is located at the southernmost tip of the United States. Travelers can reach this Key West Gay Resort via a scenic 3 1/2-hour drive from Miami or by flying into Key West International Airport with multiple daily flights from major cities.
Resort Features:
- Pool and Spa :
- At The Alexander Guesthouse, their swimming pool is the social hub, lovingly dubbed “The Heart.”
- Relax in the outdoor jacuzzi after a day of shopping, and 24/7 poolside fun awaits with comfy chaise lounges. Sun or stars, it’s always time for a splash!
- Breakfast :
- Guests can indulge in a light, tropical complimentary breakfast at the resort, featuring fresh juices, artisan breads, muffins, fruits, cereals, yogurt, egg casserole, french toast, or quiche.
- Coffee and island-style iced tea are available all day. For dietary needs, guests can inform the staff in advance to arrange suitable alternatives.
- Cocktails :
- The Pink Monkey Bar hosts daily poolside Happy Hour from 4:30 to 5:30, serving signature cocktails and making new friends. The top floor sundeck offers a captivating view of the sunset.
- With warm hospitality and a wide array of delights, the resort provides an enchanting experience for all guests to cherish.
- Sun Decks :
- This gay friendly resort offers three levels of sun decks, providing abundant semi-private outdoor relaxation spaces for guests to sunbathe. Additionally, there are clothing optional sunbathing areas on the two upper level decks.
- Wifi & Entertainment :
- In the reception area, guests can access complimentary WiFi, along with a computer for their use.
- The front desk offers a lending library with books and DVDs for a peaceful retreat.
- LGBTQ+ Inclusivity:
- They are an LGBTQA+ guesthouse, which means ALL humans are welcome! They hold an especially safe space for members of the Lesbian, Gay, Bi, Trans & Queer groups.
- They welcome all Allies as well. Just one condition, no homophobia from other guests.
Room Amenities:
Guests are treated to a delicious continental breakfast each day. This delightful spread features made-to-order eggs, homemade muffins, and a selection of tropical fruits, all served poolside.
Furthermore, every room is equipped with a flat-screen TV streaming Hulu and Netflix, providing guests with ample entertainment options during their stay.
Pricing:
Prices tend to be on the higher side for such luxurious gay resorts. On average, the minimum price for a room per night starts at around $200, while the maximum price may go up to approximately $500.
4. New Orleans House
Key West
4. New Orleans House
Google Ratings: 4.3
Known for:
- Easy access to the city’s bustling nightlife.
- Themed parties and events
Location:
This inviting oasis is conveniently located on Duval Street, one of the most vibrant and iconic areas in Key West. Guests can easily explore the city’s lively nightlife, art galleries, and eclectic restaurants, all within walking distance.
Resort Features:
- Prime Location on Duval Street:Situated on Duval Street, the resort offers easy access to the city’s lively nightlife, art galleries, and eclectic dining options.
- Clothing-Optional Pool Area:The resort boasts a relaxing clothing-optional pool area, where guests can unwind, soak up the Florida sun, and make new friends with like-minded individuals.
- Social Atmosphere:The vibrant and social atmosphere encourages guests to connect and form new friendships, fostering a sense of community among visitors.
- Extra Amenities:Guests get free access to the facilities of the Bourbon Street Complex, which includes a 15-man Jacuzzi, gym, swimming pool and a clothing-optional private sun deck area. A continental breakfast is included for guests and served on the huge balcony overlooking Duval Street, perfect for watching the world go by.
LGBTQ+ Inclusivity:
It is a male-only, clothing optional guest house. No women or non-males are allowed to protect the male guests’ right to privacy.
Room Features:
The well-appointed rooms at New Orleans House Key West offer modern-style amenities and comfortable accommodations. Each room provides a cozy retreat for guests after a day of exploring the island. From a private balcony with stunning views to contemporary decor, the resort ensures a delightful stay.
Pricing:
As a result of the high noise levels, this place is a cheaper option compared to the other Key West gay resorts. With some of the lowest prices in Key West, the New Orleans gay guesthouse is an easy pick for budget travelers. Basic rooms start as low as $230 per night.
5. The Southernmost Resort
Key West
5. The Southernmost Resort
Google Ratings: 4.2
Known for:
- Oceanfront Pools with a vibrant atmosphere
- Multiple Swimming Pools
Location:
1319 Duval St, Key West, FL 33040, United States.
Southernmost Beach Resort Key West is an exquisite waterfront escape, nestled in the heart of the iconic Key West, Florida. It’s located right by the beach so you’re never far from an ocean view.
Resort Features:
- Stunning Waterfront Location: Southernmost Beach Resort Key West enjoys a prime waterfront location, offering guests mesmerizing views of the glistening Atlantic Ocean. The resort’s idyllic setting creates a serene ambiance that enhances the overall experience.
- Proximity to Duval Street: Situated just steps away from Duval Street, the heart of Key West’s vibrant entertainment and local gay scene, guests have easy access to a variety of restaurants, gay bars, shops, and galleries, making it a perfect location to explore the island’s lively attractions.
- Tranquil Spa at Southernmost Beach Resort: This key west gay resort’s Spa offers a haven of relaxation and rejuvenation. Guests can indulge in a range of soothing treatments and therapies, from massages to facials, designed to nourish the body, mind, and spirit.
- Multiple Swimming Pools: Southernmost Beach Resort boasts multiple swimming pools, providing various options for guests to unwind and enjoy the sunshine. Among these is the adults-only tranquility pool, providing a serene and peaceful environment for those seeking a more private and calm setting.
- Water Sports Facilities: Adventure enthusiasts can take advantage of the resort’s water sports facilities. Whether it’s snorkeling, kayaking, or paddleboarding, guests can explore the captivating waters surrounding the island.
- Fitness Center: For those looking to maintain their fitness routines, the resort offers a fully-equipped fitness center with state-of-the-art exercise equipment, ensuring guests can stay active during their stay.
- Bike Rentals: Southernmost Beach Resort provides bike rentals, a popular way to explore Key West’s charming streets and scenic beauty. Guests can pedal through the island’s picturesque neighborhoods and immerse themselves in its unique culture.
LGBTQ+ Inclusivity:
Southernmost Beach Resort Key West takes great pride in its long-standing commitment to LGBTQ+ inclusivity. This key west gay resort fosters a welcoming and supportive environment for adult-only guests, irrespective of their sexual orientation or gender identity.
Room Features:
Each accommodation is beautifully appointed and exudes a sense of comfort and sophistication, providing an inviting retreat after a day of adventure.
Many of this key west gay resort’s accommodations feature private balconies, offering guests the opportunity to relish stunning views and enjoy the gentle ocean breeze from the comfort of their rooms.
Pricing:
Their standard room rate is minimum $250 to maximum $350 per night. Rates tend to be higher for such a luxurious hotel retreat with multiple pools.
6. Hyatt Centric Key West Resort & Spa
Key West
6. Hyatt Centric Key West Resort & Spa
Google Ratings: 4.4
Known for:
- Breathtaking oceanfront location
- Serene and upscale spa for ultimate relaxation
Location:
Key West, FL 33040, United States.
This exquisite resort is nestled on the beautiful island of Key West, Florida, offering a prime waterfront location on Front Street, right in the heart of Old Town.
Resort Features:
- Rejuvenating Spa Offering: The on-site spa at Hyatt Centric Key West Resort offers a variety of rejuvenating treatments and massages to help guests unwind and indulge in a blissful experience.
- Oceanfront Pool with Stunning Views: Guests can bask in the Florida sun while lounging by the resort’s oceanfront pool.
- On-Site Restaurants and Bars:This key west resort boasts a selection of on-site restaurants and bars, offering a diverse range of culinary delights. Guests can savor delicious dishes and creative cocktails while enjoying the charming atmosphere of Key West.
- Fitness Center: For health-conscious travelers, Hyatt Centric Key West Resort provides a 24-hour fitness center. Guests can stay active and invigorated during their vacation by using modern exercise equipment and facilities.
- Water Sports and Bike Rentals: Adventure seekers can dive into an array of water sports activities, such as paddleboarding or kayaking, right from the resort’s doorstep.
LGBTQ+ Inclusive:
The resort prides itself on fostering a warm and accepting environment for adults-only guests, including LGBTQ+ travelers. With a commitment to inclusivity, every visitor can feel respected and valued during their time at the resort.
Room Features:
The resort offers well-appointed guest rooms designed with a modern and elegant touch. Each room is thoughtfully furnished with premium amenities, ensuring a comfortable and relaxing stay.
Some rooms at Hyatt Centric Key West Resort have private balconies that offer breathtaking views of the ocean, allowing guests to wake up to the sight and sound of the sparkling waves.
Pricing:
At the Hyatt Centric Key West Resort, guests can expect an elevated experience, reflected in the rates starting at approximately $480 per night.
7. The Mermaid & The Alligator
Key West
7. The Mermaid & The Alligator
Google Ratings: 4.8
Known for:
- Charming bed and breakfast in Key West’s historic Old Town.
- Southern charm and modern comforts blend seamlessly.
Location:
729 Truman Avenue, Key West, 33040, United States.
At the end of the rainbow, the island city of Key West sits at the very tip of US HWY 1.
Resort features:
- Lush Gardens and Tranquil Ambiance: Surrounded by lush tropical gardens, the resort provides a serene and peaceful ambiance, creating an oasis of relaxation amidst the vibrant energy of Key West.
- Outdoor Pool for Relaxation and Enjoyment: The resort features a shimmering outdoor pool, inviting guests to take a refreshing dip and bask in the Florida sunshine, providing the perfect setting to unwind and rejuvenate.
- Thoughtfully Decorated Common Areas: The inn’s common areas are tastefully decorated with attention to detail, offering inviting spaces for guests to mingle with fellow travelers or savor moments of tranquility.
- Individually Designed Rooms with Unique Character: Each room at The Mermaid & The Alligator is thoughtfully designed with its own unique character, showcasing a blend of distinctive decor and charming accents.
- Modern Comforts : The resort seamlessly blends historical charm with modern comforts, providing amenities that cater to guests’ needs and desires.
- Charming Bed and Breakfast Experience: With its intimate and welcoming atmosphere, The Mermaid & The Alligator promises guests a charming bed and breakfast experience that leaves a lasting impression of tranquility and joy.
LGBTQ+ Inclusive:
The Mermaid & The Alligator proudly embraces LGBTQ+ travelers, fostering a warm and inclusive atmosphere, where all guests can feel comfortable and cherished.
Room Features:
Each room at The Mermaid & The Alligator is individually designed, boasting its own unique character and charm. Guests can expect a blend of antique furnishings, luxurious linens, and modern comforts, ensuring a restful and memorable stay.
Many rooms open onto private porches or balconies, allowing guests to soak in the tropical ambiance and enjoy the gentle island breeze.
Pricing:
Prices are moderate – this is a sophisticated and peaceful resort where you can switch off. Prices start at $290.
Final Thoughts
Adi and I always love creating these handcrafted guides to the top stays around the world—and this list of 7 Best Key West Gay Resorts & Stays was certainly no exception!
In my opinion, Key West is a true paradise for LGBTQ+ travelers, and these 7 gay resorts are the perfect havens to experience the island’s magic.
I’ve been lucky enough to experience it all, from the vibrant, party-like atmosphere to the warm and accepting hospitality.
Whether you’re looking for relaxation, adventure, or a celebration of love, Key West has it all.
So pack your bags and don’t forget to bring your pride.
Thanks for reading our curated guide to the very Best Gay Resorts in Key West All Ranges!
Don’t forget to share this list with your entire travel crew!
We use affiliate links and may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you. Learn more in our privacy policy.
Varsha & Adi
Living amidst Bali’s tropical paradise, Varsha & Adi are dedicated full-time travel bloggers, driven by a passion for all things tropical. Their objective is to empower like-minded nature enthusiasts to chase their dreams. Through their insightful advice and captivating stories, they act as companions, igniting a desire for unforgettable tropical escapades.
